The problem of pricing commodities pro duced in the presence of common costs by a publicly owned or regulated enterprise continues to be of great practical interest to regulators and policy makers. Crosssubsidization and matching design kellogg school of. Cross subsidization is a result of incentives caused by regulation, not of intentions to predate. Although the intuitive notions of crosssubsidy had been explicated 3 and debated in regulatory proceedings by 1970, the first work in the economics literature to rigorously define the concept of crosssubsidy was my 1975 paper, crosssubsidization. But a new spate of bopfocused businesses are emerging with innovative models for financing subsidies, including revenues from differential pricing. Prohibition of anticompetitive concerted practices. What is the rationale for cross subsidization in competitive markets, if it is not predatory. They may, for instance, engage in bundling,1 a feature already extensively studied in the literature. The est african community competition act, 2006 arrangement of sections part i preliminary provisions sections 1. Through their pricing, geographical targeting, and service delivery methodologies, mfis make their services unattractive to middleincome and wealthy individuals. We agree with appanreca that the pricing rules that we adopt in this proceeding do not preclude the commission from imposing additional cross subsidization restrictions on affiliate transactions, as appropriate, on a casebycase basis. Offering a good quality product, with appropriate customer service and at a low price point, can lead to rapid increase in sales volume and will help attract consumers spoilt for choice in a certain product category.
The implications of this for the poorest of the poor are ambiguous. This parallels movements in other parts of the united states economy. Direct costs attributable costs aservices unattributable costs ll other unattributable costs recipient of a subsidy potential recipient of a subsidy potential source of a subsidy. Cross subsidization is the practice of charging higher prices to one group of consumers to subsidize lower prices for another group. The subsidyfree serial method moulin, 1995 is essentially the only distributive method meeting ranking and dummy. The war strategy utilised by grab and uber is one of predatory pricing. They have yet to respond and instead have maintained a system of inefficient crosssubsidies. The special cost structure that is necessary for a firm to adopt a peakload pricing policy is. It is also shown that cross subsidization does not depend on an averchjohnson effect unless both markets are regulated, and that relatively strenuous conditions have to be met to have cross subsidization into unregulated markets. Any particular pricing practices observed in a market may combine elements of these different. Crosssubsidization and countervailing incentives by inaki aguirre and arantza beitia this paper studies the regulation of a multiproduct monopolist that has private information about demand conditions. Usps denies claims, says costing data follows postal commission guidelines. Regarding policy, the mere presence of price discrimination or crosssubsidy does not. Economic theory teaches that optimal economic efficiency occurs when costs and benefits are aligned, and thus cross subsidization is widely considered a symptom of economic inefficiency to be avoided in utility rate design.
Our analysis suggests that decentralization cum tacit coordination may be possible in equilibrium, with or without public disclosure of allocation. To view the pdf you will need acrobat reader, which may be downloaded from the adobe site. Cross subsidization is the characteristics feature of liner freight. A necessary costside condition for a firm to implement a cross subsidization pricing strategy is. A guide to crosssubsidization and price predation ten myths sanford v. Multiproduct firms often engage in crosssubsidization, pricing some products below cost.
Crosssubsidization restrictions on affiliate transactions. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Although elusive of measurement, cross subsidies are widely believed to have existed on a signi. A guide to cross subsidization and price predation.
From standardization and crosssubsidization to service. Competitive crosssubsidization toulouse school of economics. Firstclass mail may be subsidizing expansion of shipping services, rivals say. The core and issues of cross subsidization by haralambos d sourbis abstract this paper examines the implications of core allocations on the provision of a service to a community and the corresponding cost allocation schemes and industrial structures. Is cross subsidization a characteristic of the liner. Pdf crosssubsidies in the electricity sector researchgate. The core and issues of crosssubsidization by haralambos d sourbis abstract this paper examines the implications of core allocations on the provision of a service to a community and the corresponding cost allocation schemes and industrial structures. Aug 18, 2018 cross subsidization is the practice of funding one product with the profits generated by a different product.
Energy and heat crosssubsidies are common in developing and transitioning countries. Within these proceedings, commissions strive to avoid cross subsidization of one ratepayer by another. By generalizing moulin and shenkers 1999 distributivity axiom to costsharing methods for heterogeneous goods, we identify in each of our two theories a different serial method. Some lessons from the law and economics of regulation dwayne a. The low price is sustained by the earnings of another product sold by the same company. Productcost crosssubsidization means that if a company undercosts one of its products, it will overcost at least one of its other products. A necessary cost side condition for a firm to implement a. This term has two related, but somewhat different usages within marketing. Similarly, if a company overcosts one of its products, it will undercost at least one of its other products. I first carry out a series of reduced form regressions to detect cross subsidization in markets.
Costshifting vs crosssubsidization separating hyperplanes. Crosssubsidization and cost misallocation by regulated. Weisman this article outlines the economic principles necessary for understanding the issues of crosssubsidization and price predation using a series of straw men, or myths, involving regulatory costing and pricing. Unfortunately, the existence of cross subsidization in competitive markets is some. It has been interesting to watch all the different reactions to austin frakts piece on socalled costshifting. Thus, even when the public enterprise enjoys increasing returns to. Cross subsidies are often considered the principal mechanism through which hospitals provide unprofitable care. The standalone cost test for whether a service is a source of crosssubsidy refer. Start studying health care finance chapter 7 end of ch. No wholesale sale of electric energy may be made between a franchised public utility with captive customers and a marketregulated power sales affiliate without first receiving commission authorization for the transaction under. I first carry out a series of reduced form regressions to detect crosssubsidization in markets. Economic theory teaches that optimal economic efficiency occurs when costs and benefits are aligned, and thus crosssubsidization is widely considered a symptom of economic inefficiency to be avoided in utility rate design. Crosssubsidization, cost allocation, and tacit coordination.
This is usually done to attract customers to a newly introduced product by giving them a lower price. Modelling diversified utilities and crosssubsidization. A closely related property is the familiar dummy axiom. Principles of pricing in the case of public enterprises. What pricing policy should a public enterprise pe adopt. It has generated a rich literature in the fields of. Ferc acts to strengthen crosssubsidization rules the federal energy regulatory commission today finalized rules to ensure that ratepayers are protected against unauthorized crosssubsidies by utilities of their nonutility affiliates and to accommodate greater investment in the electric utility industry. Explain the differences between fullcost pricing and marginal cost pricing strategies. We agree with appanreca that the pricing rules that we adopt in this proceeding do not preclude the commission from imposing additional crosssubsidization restrictions on affiliate transactions, as appropriate, on a casebycase basis. It applies when the business makes a conscious decision. I the crosssub sidization implication is based on a simple formulation which implicitly appears to rely on. The practice of using profits generated from one product or service to support another provided by the same operating entity. Distributional impacts of energyheat crosssubsidization ncbi.
As a result, any crosssubsidization within the organizations customer base flows between groups that are poor. Revenues in excess of incremental cost in competitive markets allow those markets to make some contribution toward covering. This paper considers the prospect that multiproduct firms facing each other in separate markets might tacitly coordinate their production through strategic common service cost allocations and mutually benefit from such action as a consequence. Subsidies are to the rent and utilities sector is evident, as the effect tax rate is. Cross subsidization is the practice of charging higher prices to one type of consumers to artificially lower prices for another group.
Keelerttt introduction there is movement toward more reliance on competition and less on regulation in the health care sector. If you have private insurance, that might be good for you. While upholding the traditional basis for the establishment of freight rate structures it disputes some of the arguments that discrimination or differential pricing policies lead to crosssubsidization of low rated by higher rated cargoes. Accc tests for assessing crosssubsidy the formal definition of crosssubsidy that has developed in the economic literature comprises two tests that compare a services revenues to different cost concepts1. Faulhaber the problem of pricing commodities produced in the presence of common costs by a publicly owned or regulated enterprise continues to be of great practical interest to regulators and policy makers. Consider a cost function c for which the marginal cost of one of the demands, z. Heald departmentofaccountancy,universityofaberdeen received february1997.
International experience with reforming public enterprises the oecd undertook a study on reforming public enterprises14 in 1998 by examining the reform experience in australia, netherlands, spain, switzerland and the uk. Roadblocks on the road to more intelligent telephone pricing david l. Grab vs uber, and the economics behind their price war. Usps, rivals and mailers knock heads over alleged cross. These models may rely on one of many pricing structures, including. Costshifting vs crosssubsidization matthew martin 3262015 08.
Cross subsidization and multiproduct strategies in. A significant amount of the literature on special education finance focuses on financial incentives embedded in state funding systems. Rowland hill and the economics of crosssubsidy and. Within these proceedings, commissions strive to avoid crosssubsidization of one ratepayer by another. Product cost cross subsidization means that if a company. Crosssubsidization is a result of incentives caused by regulation, not of intentions to predate. What is the rationale for crosssubsidization in competitive markets, if it is not predatory. It is a complex problem and is not possible to lays down. A necessary cost side condition for a firm to implement a cross subsidization pricing strategy is. These refer to the costs incurred by the seller when adding one more unit of service. So yes, cross subsidization is a characteristic feature of liner freight. Prices cannot be sustainable if they involve any cross subsidy.
State trading enterprises with monopoly control over marketing agricultural exports are sometimes alleged to cross subsidize, but lack of transparency in their operations makes it difficult, if not impossible, to determine if that is the case. Productcost crosssubsidization is very common when a cost is uniformly spreadmeaning it is broadly averagedacross multiple products. Responsibility and crosssubsidization in cost sharing. Cross subsidization and multiproduct strategies in medicare. Mar 17, 2017 this term has two related, but somewhat different usages within marketing. Multiproduct rms compete through a variety of pricing strategies. This means that companies set the costs of a service i. This site is part of repec and all the data displayed here is part of the repec data set.
Crosssubsidies in the electricity sector article pdf available in competition and regulation in network industries 93. Should belowcost pricing be banned by competition laws. We show that the optimal regulation policy in this case crucially. Cross subsidization is the practice of funding one product with the profits generated by a different product. Rearrange individual pages or entire files in the desired order. As grimm 2008 points out, language in the most recent stb merger. This pricing policy crosssubsidization, however, is relevant.
Crosssubsidization definition in the cambridge english. Unfortunately, the existence of crosssubsidization in competitive markets is. Usps, rivals and mailers knock heads over alleged crosssubsidy of products. Open entry and crosssubsidization in regulated markets. A strategy where support for a product comes from the profits generated by another product. Mayott a decade ago, alfred kahn challenged regulators to adopt more efficient telephone pricing policies. Oecd glossary of statistical terms crosssubsidization. It is also shown that crosssubsidization does not depend on an averchjohnson effect unless both markets are regulated, and that relatively strenuous conditions have to be met to have crosssubsidization into unregulated markets. Principles of pricing in the case of public enterprises 2. The following draws out some issues that are reflected in the norwegian experience. Responsibility and crosssubsidization in cost sharing 4 separability the requirement that when costs are additively separable, each agent pays his or her stand alone cost.
The term applies when a company charges different prices to different groups of customers, for the same product. Norway marketisation of government services state owned. This means that one group of customers is paying for the consumption of other customers. Crosssubsidization and equity in special education funding. Cross subsidization can be a useful strategy to launch new products into a very highly competitive market. Because crosssubsidization primarily affects the marginal costs of plans, i then use a model of consumer discrete choice and impose. Weisman this article outlines the economic principles necessary for understanding the issues of crosssubsidization and price predation using a series of straw men, or.
1372 577 682 1057 1239 248 556 304 1467 1507 1353 495 1141 266 1514 670 1220 706 1107 1571 1610 265 726 746 452 1379 162 914 1386 400 600 206 613 720 292 1283 172 1341 795 1360 1053 489 898 738 605 434